An Australian court on Tuesday ruled Japanese whaling in the Antarctic illegal but admitted it had no power to stop it.
The Federal Court, in a hearing brought by the Humane Society
International, declared the Japanese in contravention of Australian
environment protection legislation because they were killing and
injuring minke and fin whales in the Australian whale sanctuary in the
Southern Ocean.
Justice James Alsop noted that Japan doesn't recognize the whale
sanctuary and society was powerless to enforce the injunction he
granted.
Environment Minister Peter Garrett skirted around the question of
whether the government would seek to enforce the injunction and try to
stop the Japanese.
"We will have an adequate and comprehensive monitoring in place,"
Garrett told reporters in Canberra. "It will enable us to have every
good opportunity to take material and information in the event that we
are able to take a case forward, which is what our intention is."
At the weekend, the environmental group Greenpeace met with success
in its 10-day effort to locate Japan's whaling fleet, which took
flight.
"For the amount of time that they run, they are not whaling,"
Greenpeace whales project leader Sara Holden said in a statement issued
from the ship Esperanza. "Our primary objective is to stop the Japanese
fleet from whaling in the Southern Ocean whale sanctuary."
The four-vessel fleet left Japan in November with the intention of
returning with 935 minke whales and 50 fin whales. Initially, 50
humpbacks were to be taken as well, but this part of the catch is in
abeyance after Australia and New Zealand led an international protest.
The new Australian government led by Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has
been accused of talking tough against whaling but doing little to stop
it. An Australian ship left Perth last week on a 20-day mission to
monitor the Japanese.
The Oceanic Viking with 30 Customs officers on board intends to
gather video evidence for a possible international court action against
the Japanese government-sponsored whaling.
Opposition environment spokesman Greg Hunt urged Rudd to deliver on
Labor Party promises and wind up pressure on the Japanese government to
stop its annual harvest.
When it was in opposition, Labor had castigated then-prime minister
John Howard for not succeeding in pressuring Tokyo to abandon whaling,
which it calls "scientific whaling."
Research whaling is allowed under an international whaling
moratorium, but critics of Japan said no research is involved in its
hunt.